Mushroom, Thyme & Lentil Pies

Mushroom, Thyme & Lentil Pies | Fig & HoneyWith all these cold rainy days piling up one after another, its obvious that winter is coming. Sooner rather than later. This makes me – 1). really really sad that I have no more Game of Thrones to watch at the moment and 2). remember how much I love casseroles, savory pies and roast dinners.

Comfort is my ultimate indulgence. More than anything in the world, I love cuddling under a blanket with a good book and cup of tea. Just add buttery crystallized ginger biscuits and that would be perfect just about now.

Mushroom, Thyme & Lentil Pies | Fig & Honey

A close second on the comfort scale is definitely a proper English roast dinner. With lovely crispy roast potatoes and yorkshire puddings drizzled with way too much gravy. Growing up this was a typical sunday dinner and even more so since I met my rather British husband. However, my desire to cut back on our meat consumption (for many different reasons) kinda makes this meal a bit obsolete.

So in hopes of finding equally comforting food, I’ve been experimenting with veggies and mushrooms in pies, casseroles and all sorts. Nothing quite replaces a full roast, but these Mushroom, Thyme & Lentil pies come quite close. Served with all of the roast dinner sides and you’re on your way to having a perfect Sunday in.

Mushroom, Thyme and Lentil Pies
Makes 4 large individual pies

  • 1/2 tbsp of olive oil
  • 1 small yellow onion, finely chopped
  • 2 small carrots, medium dice
  • 2 large cloves of garlic, finely minced
  • 500g cremini mushrooms, quartered
  • 1 1/2 cups puy or beluga lentils, cooked
  • 2 cups vegetable stock
  • 1 Tbsp tomato paste
  • 1 Tbsp soy sauce or tamari
  • 2 Tbsp dry red wine
  • 1 Tbsp dried Thyme
  • 2 Tbsp corn starch
  • Salt and Pepper to taste
  • Puff Pastry Sheet
  • 1 egg

In a large sauté pan, heat the olive oil and add in the diced onion and carrots. Cook on medium heat until the onion is translucent and softened and carrots are getting soft. Meanwhile, lightly wash and quarter all of the mushrooms.

Once the onions and carrots are softened, add in the garlic and mushrooms and let them cook for 4-5 minutes on medium high heat. The mushrooms will shrink quite a bit in size. At this point add in the lentils, vegetable stock, tomato paste, soy sauce, red wine and thyme. In a small bowl, mix together the corn starch with a small bit of tap water and then mix with the rest. Let cook for a few minutes more until the mixture comes to a boil and the sauce is thickened. Take off the heat and cover to let the flavors meld together a bit while you get the pastry ready.

Preheat the oven to 400F or according to the instructions on the puff pastry package. After leaving the pastry out for 5-10 minutes to warm up, roll it out flat onto a cutting board. Using the top edge of your ramekins as guides, cut out 4 circles to top your pies. Cut a small x into the middle of each circle so the pie can vent as it cooks in the oven.

Carefully spoon the mushroom and lentil mixture into ramekins and top with your cut pastry circles. Beat the egg in a small bowl and brush lightly onto the pastry. Place all the ramekins onto a baking sheet and put into the oven for 15-20 minutes until the pastry is brown and puffy and the inside is all oozy. Garnish with fresh thyme and serve immediately.

Mushroom, Thyme & Lentil Pies | Fig & Honey

29 thoughts on “Mushroom, Thyme & Lentil Pies

  1. i love the sound of this but instead of making a pie (too many cals) i would cook the lentils with the ingredients so they absorb all the flavours and leave out the pastry

  2. Hi Anjanee, if I were to make this as one large pie instead of individual serves, would there be anything specific to reconsider in the preparation? Thanks!!

    • Pauline – I think the recipe is just fine to use for a large pie instead of individual ones. The only thing I would say would be to use quite a deep casserole dish as opposed to a shallow one so that the filling doesn’t dry up in the oven.

      • Hi – I am also planning to make this as a side-dish for Thanksgiving, and would like to make 1 large casserole, instead of 4 ramekin-size containers. what size casserole do you recommend using the amount of ingredients above? what size casserole if I double the recipe above? thank you

        • Hi Debbie – To fit the recipe above, I would go with a 8×8 deep casserole dish. I haven’t tried to double the recipe, so I’m not sure exactly what size dish it would fit in. Perhaps try a 8×12 dish or something similar. However, it might just be easier to use two dishes so that everything gets heated through evenly and the pastry cooks properly.

  3. Hi! Did you measure 1 1/2 cups lentils before or after you cooked them… 1 1/2 uncooked lentils makes A LOT of cooked lentils… Thanks!

    • I know this is nearly a year late on this question but in case anyone else had the same question, you can use a few things for a vegan egg wash. A light brush of melted coconut oil or even just unsweetened non-dairy milk works great on a savory dish like this.

      For a sweet dish, you can whisk together a 2:1 ratio of non-dairy milk and agave, and brush that on. The non-dairy milk will give it that nice sheen, while the agave caramelizes slightly and helps form that golden crust.

  4. Anjanee, thank you for this recipe. I’ve been making it for over a year and it is the only pie recipe I use now. I double the recipe, cook the filling, fill my containers, top with puff pastry and then freeze the pies. An easy meal, just pull them out and pop in the oven. I’ve shared this recipe with many. One lady has an 18 month old and she had to start making it in a casserole dish because the toddler always wanted seconds. Fabulous!!! Thank you again.

    • Thank you Janet! I’m really happy to hear the recipe works so well for you and your friend! Who would have thought toddlers would like it too!

    • hi – I would love to prepare these ahead for a dinner party. So do you soften the puff pastry enough to top the pies, but then freeze them before baking them? And then how long would the frozen individual pies need to be baked? Thanks very much

      • Hi Janet,

        How far in advance are you trying to make these pies? I would recommend thawing and refreezing the puff pastry. If you wanted to freeze the pies, I would take them out the day before and leave them in the fridge to thaw and then add the thawed puff pastry right before you bake. You could probably experiment with frozen pies and puff pastry, but I don’t have any experience with this! Good luck!

  5. I made this last night… My husband said it was the best thing I have ever made! It was really delicious!! I am slightly sleep deprived right now with a newborn at home so it wasn’t until I got home from the grocery store that I realized I don’t have ramekins. I just threw it all into a corningware dish and covered it with the entire puff pastry sheet. It was perfect.
    Thanks for the recipe, it’s going to be one of my regulars

  6. Anjanee I used this recipe for a dinner party last night. It was well enjoyed, however the filling was very sloppy. I used a 400g tin of lentils to save some preparation time. Otherwise I think I did everything correctly. Any ideas?
    I’m glad I’ve found your website – it will help me do more cooking for the family.
    Melbourne, Australia

    • Hi Anthony,

      Not sure what went wrong with your pie. Did the tin of lentils have liquid with them? If so, was it drained? Perhaps next time you could just cook it down a bit till you get the consistency that you’re looking for! Hope that helps!


  7. My second attempt was better. Instead of 2 cups of vegetable stock I used about one. Next time I’ll try doing a real pie with pastry too and bottom. Oh no, actually Victoria wants mashed potatoes on top next time, as in Shepherd’s Pie.

    • Yum! The shepherds pie version sounds delicious – I’ll have to try that out. Might be good with mashed sweet potatoes too!

  8. Hi there, could Thisbe prepped a day ahead and removed from fridge to oven next day to cook? Looks yum but very busy Xmas day and wanted to make for Xmas :)

      • I’ll be making this for Christmas this year as well!
        Great tip about making the filling the day ahead, I might do that too :)
        Can’t wait to try it! I am hosting Christmas dinner for some meat eating friends and as a vegan I am exited to introduce them some great meat-free alternatives!

Leave a Comment